Published by: World Tibet Network News 97/05/21 08:00 GMT
07:00 p.m May 19, 1997 Eastern
WASHINGTON (Reuter) - Opponents of U.S. trade concessions to China are expected to mount the fiercest congressional battle in years to overturn President Clinton's decision to renew China's favored trading status.
While supporters of the president's decision Monday to renew China's most favored nation (MFN) status for another year remain confident of victory, opponents -- ranging from social conservatives to organized labor -- are
revving up for a fight.
The unusual coalition is blasting the move from both sides of the political
spectrum, hitting China's policies on human rights, labor rights, religious
rights, trade and abortion.
Opponents are also gathering strength from worries over the transfer this summer
of Hong Kong to China, as well as the brouhaha over charges that Beijing tried
to sway U.S. elections through illegal campaign contributions.
``With Hong Kong and campaign finance lurking in the background, it will
definitely be a tougher fight,'' a congressional aide, who requested anonymity,
said. ``A lot depends on what happens between now and the vote.''
Another congressional aide said, ``The coalition of the AFL-CIO and social
conservatives makes for a potent force.''
House Speaker Newt Gingrich said this year's decision would be closer than last
year's 286-141 vote in the House to back Clinton on MFN. But advocates and even
opponents expect the president's policy ultimately to survive.
Even if lawmakers muster enough votes to reject the president's decision --
which is considered unlikely -- opponents doubt they could round up the
two-thirds vote needed to override an expected veto from Clinton.
Congress later this summer will vote on whether to overturn Clinton's decision,
with the House voting first.
``The opponents have a better chance than they have had in the past several
years. But it still may not be enough of a margin to withstand a veto,'' said
Thea Lee, international expert at the AFL-CIO, which opposes MFN status for
China.
But even a defeat for MFN's opponents could amount to a sort of victory if the
vote is close enough.
``It represents an important turning point in the growing uneasiness among both
Democrats and Republicans over the current China trade policy,'' Lee said.
Gary Bauer, president of the conservative Family Research Council, said: ``The
president's action represents the high-water mark of the pro-MFN forces. As the
truth of the human rights violations in China reaches the American public, the
case for MFN collapses.''
A sign Clinton will face tougher sledding emerged a week ago, when an
influential House Republican leader urged the president to revoke China's MFN
status, citing Beijing's record on human rights, weapon sales and trade.
Rep. Bill Paxon of New York, a Gingrich ally who chairs meetings of the
Republican House leadership team, said current U.S. policy had yielded only ``a
Chinese regime which thumbs its nose at the United States and places its heel
on the neck of freedom.''
Democratic lawmakers echo that view.
Since Clinton ``delinked trade from human rights three years ago, the human
rights situation in China and Tibet has deteriorated, the U.S. trade deficit
with China has soared, and China's authoritarian government has continued its
sale of nuclear, chemical, missile and biological weapons technology to
dangerous countries, including Iran,'' Rep. Nancy Pelosi, a California
Democrat, said.
But supporters of the administration's policy remain confident. ``In the end,
the votes will be there for MFN,'' said Calman Cohen of the Emergency Committee
for American Trade, representing the heads of big U.S. corporations.